Reader Comments

Details, Fiction and Lawyer in Chandigarh

by Deborah Perrier (2018-10-25)


Out of them, four companies were permitted to participate in the RFP stage. Subsequently, the Nagar Nigam issued RFP for construction, operation and maintenance of modern slaughter house at Ghosipur, Meerut on July 29, 2010. It is to be borne in mind that the vouchers are not 'sold' by the appellant to its customers, as wrongly perceived by the High Court, and this fundamental mistake in understanding the whole scheme of arrangement has led to wrong conclusion by the High Court. JUDICIAL REVIEW OF PUBLIC FUNCTIONS The previous section considered susceptibility to judicial review based on the source of the power: statute or prerogative.

The courts came to recognize that an approach based solely on the source of the public authoritys power was too restrictive. 6(3)(b) to define a public authority as any person certain of whose functions are functions of a public nature, but detailed consideration of that provision is postponed until later). Concurrent findings recorded by the trial court and the first appellate court to that effect conclude the factual part of the controversy. It is not in dispute that the execution of Advocates the Promissory Note and the endorsement made by the Respondent has been satisfactorily proved at the trial.

It was further submitted that this view of the High Court knocks out the basis of the Directors order against the appellant which was impugned before the High Court and there was no necessity for the High Court to examine any other issue. Petitioners placed reliance on the last sentence which said that the action of the Government and the provisions of the legislation were plainly arbitrary and discriminatory in Advocates support of their submission that an Act could be declared unconstitutional on the ground that it is arbitrary.

We begin by looking Advocates at the first approach, based on the source of power. (2) x x x x x (3) The Management of a school including a night school shall fill up the post of the Head by appointing the senior-most member of Advocates the teaching staff (in accordance with the guidelines laid down in Schedule F from amongst those employed in a school (if it is the only school run by the Management) or schools [if there are more than one school (excluding night school) conducted by it] who fulfills the conditions laid down in sub- rule(1) and who has a satisfactory record of service.

The public function approach is, since 2000, reflected in the Civil Procedure Rules: CPR. Previous to the extant policy, FL-1 licences i. Pursuant to the aforesaid Notice, five financial and technical bids were received from five firms. retail of licence sale of foreign liquor, were auctioned by the State to private parties, which practice, as is obvious, has been discontinued. The Foreign Liquor Rules were promulgated by virtue of Sections 10 and 24 to 29 of the Abkari Act, relating to the sale of Indian Made Foreign Liquor (IMFL).

The only question that survives in the above background is whether the cheques issued by the Respondent were meant to discharge, in whole or part, any debt or other liability within the meaning of Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881. 1(2)(a)(ii), defines a claim for judicial review as a claim to the lawfulness of a decision, action or failure to act in relation to the exercise of a public function. It may also be relevant to mention that the State of Kerala made a futile foray into prohibition, but this was withdrawn in 1967.

, the institute having same status as that of Government polytechnic and not a private polytechnic, as in the case at hand. Accordingly, the Nagar Nigam again published a Notice dated June 29, 2010 inviting tenders of RFQ. The High Court has also wrongly observed that vouchers are capable of being sold by the appellant after they are brought into the limits of the city. The Appellant contended that by inviting such tenders, no public interest was being served and instead has led to the creation of a monopoly in favour of one person with respect to the mode of transportation, which in turn was detrimental to public interest.

6 The Appellant contended that Section 70 was an implied restriction on the Respondents capacity to call for such tenders. Pursuant to the aforesaid RFP, tenders were submitted by only three firms. As we noted at the outset, the term public is usually a synonym for governmental. Extending the line of argument on Section 71, the Appellant contended that the Central Government had not issued any special or general order, enabling the Respondents to give special or preferential facility in the carriage of goods to anyone who offers the highest lump sum rate.

The only exception to Section 70 is Section 71, which can be exercised only on the discretion of the Central Government, for the purpose of public interest. The Appellant submitted that the content of the affidavit filed by the Respondent ran counter to the impugned Notification. (Similar terminology is used in the Human Rights Act 1998 s. Since 1987 they have developed an additional approach to determining susceptibility based on by the type of function performed by the decision-maker.

These vouchers are printed for a particular customer, which are used by the said customer for distribution to its employees and these vouchers are not transferrable at all. On behalf of the appellant, it was pointed out that the judgment under appeal has correctly held that the Government Rules 2012 apply only to Government polytechnic or equivalent institute, i. The existence of a Union Territory, Mahe, within the State of Kerala, and boundaries with the States of Karnataka and Tamil Nadu where the sale or consumption of liquor is not prohibited indubitably makes it almost impossible for the State to venture into prohibition.

As at present, the private sector is not permitted to manufacture IMFL and there is only one State owned distillery.